Public Sector contractor wins IR35 case

18th June 2018

HMRC have lost a second IR35 case this year, and their second case against the same contractor, putting into doubt their own understanding of the IR35 rules. Ian Wells, director of personal service company Jensal Software Limited provided his services to the Department of Work and Pensions via a recruitment agency during 2012 and 2013.

HMRC would have been keen to win a case against a public sector contractor to bolster the IR35 reforms that began on 1 April 2017. However, the tribunal judge found several factors that meant the contract was outside IR35.

Mr Wells was not subject to the level of control that would constitute a contract of employment.

A clause in the contract allowed a substitute to be provided, and although not utilised, meant the balance was shifted away from employment. In fact, Mr Wells admitted he had requested the addition of such a clause which HMRC insisted proved the clause was a sham. Interestingly, the judge reasoned that inserting a clause did not negate the right to use it and rely on it.

HMRC generally view all public sector contracts to have Mutuality of Obligation – an obligation on both parties to provide and accept work. Judge Jennifer Dean decided there was not enough of an obligation to demonstrate a contract of employment.

 With HMRC currently consulting on private sector contractors, their decision to pursue this case casts doubt over their ability to recognise whether a contractor belongs inside or outside IR35.

 

 

Other items in Blogs
Ellen Carter
11th August 2022 Revisit your remuneration?

For many SME owner-managed businesses, the tax optimum director remuneration structure for many years has been one of a low salary accompanied by high dividends. This allows Companies to take advantage of low dividend tax rates and, in many cases, no employers national insurance to be paid by the company (if paid at the Secondary…

Jaimie King
10th August 2022 Seeing Double: New Recovery Loan Scheme begins

While one government-backed Recovery Loan Scheme (RLS) ends, another opens.   The previous RLS closed on 30th June 2022, but to follow this the government have introduced a new RLS scheme to support businesses through the out-turn of the pandemic, expected to be accessible after 1st August 2022.   The New Recovery Loan Scheme Government…

Charlie Whittle
10th August 2022 Annual Allowance for NHS pensions

What is the annual allowance? The annual allowance for the 2022/23 tax year is £40,000 and each year this is compared with your pension input amounts. Your pension input is defined as the increase or growth in the capital value of your NHS pension benefits across all pension schemes. Any growth in excess of the…

Jake Day
8th August 2022 TRS Registrations: This deadline may apply to you

  1st September 2022 – This deadline may apply to you!   If you hold property or investments on behalf of another person, HMRC may consider this as a reportable trust arrangement. This may mean that you need to register on the Trust Registration Service (TRS) before 1st September 2022.   New legislation now in…

Megan Turner
4th August 2022 Charity Commission annual return: Planned Changes

The Charity Commission has launched a consultation regarding changes to the annual return.   There are a number of new questions, taking the total questions from 36 to 52, although only 32 will be compulsory. The aim of the new questions is to make the annual return more comprehensive, by gaining information around charity’s income…

Ben Beech
3rd August 2022 MP’s call for Government to Introduce Essential User Rebate

The All-Party Parliamentary Group for Road Freight and Logistics has today (27 July 2022) urged the Government to approve the introduction of an Essential User Rebate of no less than 15 pence per litre for operators within the logistics sector to combat the effects of soaring fuel prices and inflation.   The call has come…