Potato store tribunal ruling

28th July 2021

In 2019 the first tier tribunal ruled in a case concerning a grain store that the entire structure qualified as plant and consequently gave rise to a capital allowance claim, by reason of it being a silo. As a consequences of this decision there have been a number of claims for capital allowances both in respect of grain stores built since that date and indeed for a number built prior to the case.

 

I am delighted to read that there has now been a further first tier tribunal ruling which has considered the eligibility of an agricultural store for capital allowances as plant. In this later case the building was a potato store. The claim to allowances succeeded as the tribunal ruled that the store qualified both as a silo and as a cold store. The decision concerning it being a cold store was particularly interesting as there was no refrigeration facility within the store.

 

It will be interesting to see whether HM Revenue & Customs appeal against this decision and to read the technical commentary which will doubtless follow. Although the case considered the storage of crisping potatoes there is at least an argument that similar considerations would apply to the storage of chipping potatoes, thus potentially making the case more relevant to a greater number of taxpayers. Certainly my colleagues and I will be reviewing which clients have constructed potato stores in recent years and as the consequences of this decision become clearer, considering where claims for relief can be submitted.

 

Other items in Agriculture
James Selby
8th October 2021 Annual Investment Allowance (AIA) – Maximising tax relief

The chance to take advantage of the generous temporary uplift in the AIA annual limit of £1,000,000 is coming to an end when it is due to revert to £200,000 from 1 January 2022.   It is a perfect time to plan to capitalise on claiming 100% tax relief on qualifying purchases without getting caught…

James Cater
30th September 2021 New Environmental Land Management Scheme

As we move towards the end of the Single Farm Payment and the introduction of the Environmental Land Management Scheme the possibilities for the development of a soil carbon market is attracting attention. Standardisation in the measurement of volumes and permanence of carbon sequestered is badly needed but it is reported that some methods suggest…

Andrew Band
21st September 2021 Invitation: Whitings Farming Seminar

We are pleased to announce that our Annual Farming Seminar this year will be held virtually, on 3rd November 2021 at 10.30am.   This is in collaboration with Sebastien Mallet, CEO of ODA UK.   Agenda 10.30 Welcome from Chairman, Andrew Band 10.45 Sebastien Mallet, ODA – UK & World grain and oilseeds price perspective…

James Cater
28th July 2021 Potato store tribunal ruling

In 2019 the first tier tribunal ruled in a case concerning a grain store that the entire structure qualified as plant and consequently gave rise to a capital allowance claim, by reason of it being a silo. As a consequences of this decision there have been a number of claims for capital allowances both in…

James Cater
27th May 2021 DEFRA’s Lump Sum Exit Scheme

DEFRA have now issued the consultation document regarding the lump sum payment for exiting agriculture. Having listened to the NFU webinar concerning this it seems to me that the lump sum, whilst being attractive from a cash flow perspective, has little else too recommend it. Clearly we have a lot more to learn and in…

Ben Kilby
25th March 2021 I hear a rumour…

I hear a rumour that Lloyds Agricultural banking team based in Edinburgh has been disbanded and merged within other teams around the country. Although some within the new regional teams may have some knowledge of agriculture it has been suggested that customers felt that this was not important. It seems that the agricultural specialism within…