Changes for Farmers in VAT flat rate scheme

30th October 2017

 

The decision has recently been published in a European Court of Justice case, Shields and Sons Partnership v the Commissioners for HM Revenue & Customs. The case revolved around the authority of HMRC to remove the partnership from the VAT flat rate scheme for farmers. It is reported that the partnership had benefited over 7 years from using the scheme to the tune of £374,884.23. In most situations the VAT flat rate scheme offers little or no advantage as the 4% of turnover which the farmer receives from using the scheme seldom equates to the amount of input VAT which he is precluded from recovering. In the Shields case it is reported that the appellant reared cattle purchased from an associated company before selling them to a processor. In these circumstances it may be presumed that the majority of the VAT carrying expenses were incurred by the company providing the calves.  It was held that HMRC had no general discretion to remove individual farmers from the scheme.

 

For the report of the case visit:-

http://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf?text=&docid=195429&pageIndex=0&doclang=en&mode=req&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=1283901

 

To view HMRC’s VAT Notice 700/46 dealing with the scheme go to :-

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/vat-notice-70046-agricultural-flat-rate-scheme/vat-notice-70046-agricultural-flat-rate-scheme

Other items in Agriculture
Andrew Band
17th April 2024 Whitings 2024 Annual Farming Seminar

Our Whitings 2024 Annual Farming Seminar is just around the corner.   Farming always has to cope with changing environment, weather, commodity prices, political changes, etc. This year these challenges feel heightened and this is why we are pleased to welcome back speakers from the Andersons Centre to inform us of these changes and what…

Louise Bassett
21st March 2024 Don’t Delay: Farming Equipment and Technology Fund Deadlines

Earlier this week, DEFRA added the closing dates for the Farming Equipment and Technology Fund (FETF).   If you’re a farmer, horticulturist, forestry owner or contractor to the any of the aforementioned, and you’re looking to improve productivity, manage slurry or improve animal health and welfare through the use of new technology and equipment, don’t…

Louise Bassett
21st February 2024 How is the government supporting farmers?

Let’s ask the question, ‘How is the government supporting farmers?’   DEFRA shared a press release from the Prime Minister yesterday, citing his and his party’s commitment to farmers and rural communities.   We already know that Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) and Countryside Stewardship payments are being increased across the board by approximately 10%, but…

Whitings LLP
18th January 2024 Farming Group Newsletter – Issue 23

Over And Out   This will be the final Agricultural Newsletter produced during my tenure as Chair of our Farming Group and it would not be right if taxation was not considered in at least one contribution. Mike Blackledge provides for this with a review of the consequences of multiple rates of Corporation Tax where…

Liz Simpson
10th October 2023 Sick Pay: Farming Industry

The Farming Industry has some marked differences is sick pay legislation, PAYE regulations don’t pay sick pay over the statutory daily rate currently standing at £21.88 per day and commencing from the 4th consecutive day of absence. Statutory Sick Pay (SSP) is payable for the first 28 weeks of sickness, after which the employee can…

Whitings LLP
18th July 2023 Farming Group Newsletter: Issue 22

Sticks and Carrots – No Change Then Over recent years farmers have been incentivised periodically to change their crop choices. We have had ‘yellow years’ as Oilseed Rape coloured our landscape and ‘blue years’ when Linseed was dominant. I suspect that ‘green years’ may be the next favoured colour and I’m not just thinking of…