An update for NHS staff on the annual allowance charge for 2019/20

24th February 2020

Current Issues

The introduction of the tapered pension annual allowance from 6 April 2016 has been a contentious issue for many, in particular senior NHS staff members.

The legislation change means that, for high income individuals, the annual pension allowance may be reduced from £40,000 to a minimum of £10,000. Pension inputs in excess of the annual allowance continue to be taxable at marginal income tax rates however; the tapering has meant a significantly higher number of individuals are falling fowl of the excess charge.

This change has disproportionately affected NHS staff members as the NHS offer a defined benefit pension scheme. Broadly speaking, this calculates annual pension input by reference to the growth in the pension pot, which is affected by pensionable pay.

The only option to control the growth in NHS pension pots is therefore to reduce pensionable earnings for the year, meaning many are opting not to take on any additional shifts, in an effort to avoid the huge tax charges that are hitting them.

Since the introduction of the tapering, the only attempt made to help those effected by an excess charge has been for the ‘scheme pays’ facility to be extended to cover the whole tax liability arising (previously this was restricted to only cover certain circumstances). The downside of the scheme pays facility however, is that it reduces the overall value of an individual’s pension pot on retirement and is therefore not a simple fix.

Looking to the future

In the long term, the Treasury are consulting on ways to amend the current annual allowance legislation to help mitigate the somewhat unintended effects of the tapering. This will be good news for not just NHS staff but also other higher earners.

They are expecting to announce the outcome of the current consultation document following the 11 March budget, but have confirmed that any changes will not take effect from the 2019/20 tax year.

NHS England has therefore stepped in as a short term measure for those affected by the charge in 2019/20.

For those members who opt for ‘scheme pays’ in 2019/20, the NHS have agreed to make an additional payment into the member’s pension pot on retirement, equal to the value paid out for the tax charge in 2019/20, to avoid any loss to the individual.

There are however a number of caveats.  For example, the offer applies to NHS scheme charges only, ignoring all pensions held outside of the NHS, and is also not available to cover any excess arising from Additional Voluntary Contributions (AVC’s) made.

It is therefore worth contacting your accountant and/or financial advisors to ensure you are making the most of the available help in 2019/20.

If you would like to discuss the above with us in more detail, please contact us.

*Details of the calculation required to determine if you are a high income individual are not included above however these are available on the gov website here:

Other items in Blogs
Barbara Nicholas
25th May 2022 A Grim Reap?

We work hard to improve our lot and most of us hope that our loved ones will reap some benefit from our endeavours. But assuming that we don’t manage to spend all the fruits of our labours, the taxman is lurking. And he will take a sizeable chunk if we don’t plan sensibly.   The…

Jake Day
17th May 2022 We’re Hiring: Tax Careers at Whitings

With a vacancy now open for a Trainee Tax Technician in our Bury St Edmunds office, we’d like to give you a closer look at the highlights of choosing a career in tax – and also the highlights of choosing Whitings as your employer. Why choose tax? The common misconception with a career in tax…

Peter Brown
16th May 2022 e-Commerce: Are you finding keeping your business’s records a nightmare?

Understanding how to account for your business’s transactions with online selling platforms can be complicated. Ensuring that you are submitting the correct information to HMRC can be tricky as not all platforms have the same VAT treatment.   A2X could make your life easier by saving you time and headaches from the complex world of…

Louise Bassett
10th May 2022 Defra Announce 50% BPS advance

As farmers face being squeezed with price increases for inputs due to the situation in Ukraine and worldwide gas and energy prices, DEFRA have announced that the RPA will advance 50% of the value of BPS payments to farmers from the end of July 2022 with the balance to be paid from December as normal.…

Luke Bacon
10th May 2022 HMRC starts chasing up SEISS overpayments

HMRC has started to recover overpayments of Self-employment Income Support Scheme (SEISS) grants. From April, HMRC is writing to taxpayers whose entitlement to the fourth or the fifth SEISS grant has reduced by more than £100 to ask them to repay amounts that were overpaid. Entitlement to the fourth and fifth SEISS grants can be affected…

Charlie Whittle
5th May 2022 TRS – Information required and annual declarations

Intended as a companion to: TRS Who should register and when. The TRS will collect information about the trust and its trustees, settlors and other individuals or organisations exercising control. This will include: Name of the trust. Date the trust was created. Whether the trust is an express trust or not. Details of the trust…