Share Valuation Test Case

6th June 2015

Mr & Mrs Foulser v HMRC: interesting test case on valuing shares in unquoted company.
Business owners may only have to value shares in their family company on a few occasions during their lifetime (eg for commercial share transfers, gifts or capital taxes calculations), but the numbers involved are likely to be material. So a recent test case is helpful in shedding further light on what the Courts consider to be the correct basis for such valuations.

In this case, as you would expect, both parties advanced arguments in support of extreme valuations (initially £14m apart). The taxpayer wished to use the BDO P/E index applied to an adjusted maintainable profit figure, whilst HMRC wished to use a P/E multiple extracted from a simple quoted business. Further differences existed concerning control premiums and minority shareholding discounts. The Tribunal found flaws in both valuations, although favoured the HMRC basis, with adjustments for the discounts applied.

As always, information is king, and this example further helps our predictions on how Courts might arrive at other future unquoted share valuations.

Blog entry by: Andrew Winearls.

Other items in Blogs
Luke Bacon
11th January 2022 31-Jan-22 tax: can it be reduced?

For those clients that prepare self-assessment personal tax returns, 31 January is always tax payment day. This tax will primarily be based on your personal income for the tax year ended 5 April 2021, potentially made up of 2 components: The balancing payment for 2020/21 (total 2020/21 tax less 31-Jan-21 and 31-Jul-21 payments on account).…

Vanessa Pearson
11th January 2022 Chancellor announces £1bn in grants

On 21 December 2021, Chancellor of the Exchequer, Rishi Sunak, unveiled a £1 billion COVID-19 fund, including cash grants of up to £6,000 per premises for each eligible firm in the hospitality and leisure sector.   Mr Sunak said the government would also help certain firms with the cost of sick pay for COVID-related absences. The Chancellor also announced…

Jodie Pheby
6th January 2022 HMRC deadline now effectively 28-Feb

Due to the continuing difficulties that Covid continues to present, today HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) have announced they are waiving late filing and late payment penalties for Self Assessment taxpayers for one month – giving extra time, if needed, to complete your 2020 to 2021 tax return and pay any tax due.   HMRC…

Ben Kilby
5th January 2022 Home office pod: the tax pros & cons

If there is one question I have been asked by our business clients more than any other since the pandemic began, it is “How can I tax efficiently purchase a garden home office pod, to run my business from”?   Unfortunately there is no simple single answer to this question, and best advice will depend…

Steven Denton
5th January 2022 HMRC latest guidance for employers

HMRC has published the latest edition of the Employer Bulletin. This guidance for employers, and their agents, includes articles on: reporting PAYE information in real time when payments are made early at Christmas preventing and correcting payroll errors Health and Social Care – National Insurance contribution increase UK-Swiss Convention on Social Security Coordination COVID-19 –…

Ian Piper
4th January 2022 Business credit rating: top 10 tips

For some businesses having a strong credit rating is fundamental to their future success. It can affect availability of supplier credit, the ability to borrow and eligibility to be on customer/prospect tender lists as an approved supplier. For many other businesses, however, this credit rating is totally irrelevant. Experian is one of the major rating…