Share Valuation Test Case

6th June 2015

Mr & Mrs Foulser v HMRC: interesting test case on valuing shares in unquoted company.
Business owners may only have to value shares in their family company on a few occasions during their lifetime (eg for commercial share transfers, gifts or capital taxes calculations), but the numbers involved are likely to be material. So a recent test case is helpful in shedding further light on what the Courts consider to be the correct basis for such valuations.

In this case, as you would expect, both parties advanced arguments in support of extreme valuations (initially £14m apart). The taxpayer wished to use the BDO P/E index applied to an adjusted maintainable profit figure, whilst HMRC wished to use a P/E multiple extracted from a simple quoted business. Further differences existed concerning control premiums and minority shareholding discounts. The Tribunal found flaws in both valuations, although favoured the HMRC basis, with adjustments for the discounts applied.

As always, information is king, and this example further helps our predictions on how Courts might arrive at other future unquoted share valuations.

Blog entry by: Andrew Winearls.

Other items in Blogs
Joe Fretwell
1st July 2022 Is your PAYE code correct?

With the rising cost of living, it has never been more important to ensure you are paying the correct amount of tax through your PAYE tax code. It is important to understand your tax code, any changes to this and why your tax code on your payslip is what it is. There are many reasons…

Ruth Pearson
23rd June 2022 Changes to National Insurance

In April 2022 we saw Employee’s National Insurance Contributions increase by 1.25% from 12% to 13.25%, as part of the Governments Health and Social Care levy. Employer’s National insurance also increased from 13.8% to 15%. From April 2023, the health and social care levy will be paid separately to National Insurance and become a tax…

James Selby
23rd June 2022 Pensions Contributions: Maximise tax relief

We are seeing more and more cases of individuals missing out on claiming higher rate tax relief on their employee pension contributions especially where they are not in self-assessment and required to file tax returns.   Where employers have enrolled their staff to make employees pension contributions via a ‘relief at source’ scheme, the contributions…

Paul Jefferson
14th June 2022 VAT Penalty Changes

A new penalty regime will come into effect for VAT periods starting on or after 1 January 2023. The changes will impact the charges for missing VAT filing and payment deadlines and will be replacing the current surcharge system. These changes place continued importance on being up to date with your VAT returns, aware of…

Liz Simpson
13th June 2022 NIC: All Change!

HMRC Changes to the National Insurance contributions for 2022-2023 tax year, are you confused? Due to the COVID-19 strain on the NHS, the government announced that they would be increasing the National Insurance contributions by 1.25% as a means to increase spending on health and social care. The Health and Social Care Levy was applied…

Jaimie King
10th June 2022 30-Jun-22: Covid Recovery loan deadline approaching

Time is running out for businesses to apply for Recovery Loans, the follow on Covid-support product from the CBILS.   In order to qualify for the Recovery Loan Scheme (RLS), your business has to have been affected by Covid-19 and you have to apply and have received the funds by 30th June 2022. The RLS…