EIS Test Case: Capital gains tax exit exemption not linked to income tax entry claim.

4th September 2018

In a recent HMRC test case (Ames v CRC), the Upper Tribunal considered whether it was necessary for EIS income tax relief to have been claimed when an EIS investment was made, for the transaction to then potentially qualify for exemption from capital gains tax when the investment was sold.

For the case in question, the usual EIS1 application process was followed; resulting in HMRC issuing an EIS2 certificate to the company, which in turn they converted into EIS3 certificates for the shareholders. Initial income tax relief was not claimed by one individual taxpayer shareholder as he did not have high enough taxable income that tax year to cover the deduction. When this shareholder realised his investment, for around £1/3m, having sought telephone advice from HMRC, no capital gains tax disclosures were made on his self-assessment return. HMRC became aware of this omission from the tax return and initially interpreted the EIS legislation as the EIS income tax claim being a prerequisite for a subsequent EIS capital gains tax exemption. Accordingly, they then raised a discovery assessment for £72k tax. The taxpayer appealed this interpretation to the First Tier Tribunal, but lost. He then took the decision to the Upper Tribunal, and won.

This test case is helpful in clarifying that these two EIS tax benefits, together with EIS Deferral Relief, all operate independently of each other.

Disclaimer - All information in this post was correct at time of writing.
Other Blogs
Byron Roberts
26th March 2024 Making Tax Digital for Income Tax coming soon

Making Tax Digital for Income Tax will soon be upon us.   Over the past few years’ rents have been increasing and will continue to increase as inflation remains high. Many landlords will now be affected or will be coming close to the qualifying limits. With April 2026 fast approaching for those with qualifying income…

Amanda Newman
25th March 2024 Finance available for start ups

Did you know that there is finance available for start ups?   Starting in business can be an expensive task and a lot of businesses are not always aware of the funding that is available from the government to help with this.   Where to start The most popular is the government backed start up…

Harriet Sim
25th March 2024 The end of Furnished Holiday Lettings

The recent Budget announcements will bring an end to the tax advantages afforded to the owners of Furnished Holiday Lettings (FHL) and set them apart from the owners of normal residential properties.   At present, qualifying FHL’s provide a number of tax advantages: Unrestricted tax relief for mortgage interest Entitlement to claim capital allowances, including…

Megan Turner
22nd March 2024 Directors’ Responsibilities

What are directors’ responsibilities? As a director, you are legally responsible for running the company. This must be done in line with both the articles of association and Companies Act 2006.   A key role is to ensure that all statutory reporting requirements are met. This includes, but is not limited to: Filing the annual…

Louise Bassett
21st March 2024 Don’t Delay: Farming Equipment and Technology Fund Deadlines

Earlier this week, DEFRA added the closing dates for the Farming Equipment and Technology Fund (FETF).   If you’re a farmer, horticulturist, forestry owner or contractor to the any of the aforementioned, and you’re looking to improve productivity, manage slurry or improve animal health and welfare through the use of new technology and equipment, don’t…

Shamus Chaplin
21st March 2024 Removal of Multiple Dwellings Relief for SDLT

On 6th March 2024, the abolition of the Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) relief known as Multiple Dwellings Relief (MDR) was announced. The Reasoning HMRC’s tax reliefs evaluation programme has determined that MDR has not satisfied its original objectives. They have concluded that there have been numerous cases where the relief has been abused and…