Construction firm wins R&D tax relief case

27th October 2021

A tax tribunal has made a landmark ruling against HMRC, by declaring that the construction taxpayer (Quinn) was validly entitled to claim SME research and development (R&D) tax relief totalling approximately £1m, even though this work was specifically undertaken to order for a customer, which would normally mean the ‘subsidised’ rule would prohibit eligibility under the SME scheme.

Quinn’s building projects usually generate new technological knowledge or capability, which the company was then able to carry forward and exploit in future commercial work. HMRC accepted that Quinn was an SME, that it had carried out R&D activities and had expended sums on the R&D which it was entitled to deduct in computing its taxable profits for the relevant periods for corporation tax purposes. However, HMRC denied Quinn the enhanced SME R&D relief (worth an additional tax reduction of 25p for every £1 of eligible spend) arguing that the R&D was carried out during the time where Quinn was providing services to its clients for which it received payment to cover the claimed R&D expenditure, and so was ‘subsidised’ indirectly, and thus it should be claimed as RDEC R&D relief instead (worth only an additional tax reduction of 11p for every £1 of eligible spend).

The case focused on the complex technical argument over what ‘subsidised’ was intended to include. The tribunal ruled that a fair reading of the legislation would conclude that it is not intended to apply in circumstances such as Quinn completing R&D in the course of providing its services where there is no clear link between the price paid by the customer and the R&D expenditure. The tribunal stated that ‘it would be wholly out of kilter with the overall SME scheme if an SME were to be denied enhanced R&D relief solely because, as is usual and to be expected of an entity carrying out a trade on a commercial basis, it seeks to recover some or all of the relevant costs of the R&D under it its commercial contracts with its clients entered into in the course of its ordinary trading activities’.

The appeal against HMRC’s initial view was therefore granted by the Tribunal. HMRC have not made an appeal against the Tribunal decision, as at the time of writing, so the precedent is hopefully now set.

This is an interesting judgement which will allow many taxpayers to now claim R&D relief under the more generous SME scheme rather than under the RDEC scheme. Previously submitted claims should be reviewed to see if they are still within time to be amended.

 

Other items in Business Tax
Vanessa Pearson
11th December 2021 Tax exemption of Christmas parties/gifts

Businesses may be hoping they can hold their annual Christmas parties this month. Providing the event is annual, open to all employees and the total cost, including VAT, is less than £150 per person (including non employee guest attendees), this will be a non-taxable benefit in kind (ie free of PAYE tax and National Insurance…

Vanessa Pearson
9th December 2021 Advisory fuel rates for company cars

New company car advisory fuel rates have been published and took effect from 1 December 2021.   The guidance states: ‘you can use the previous rates for up to one month from the date the new rates apply’. The rates only apply to employees using a company car.   The advisory fuel rates for journeys…

Vanessa Pearson
10th November 2021 IR35 tax bill of £281k for Sky presenter

HRMC continue their campaign against broadcasters, with another successful case against former Sky presenter Dave Clark. Mr Clark presented and commentated on professional darts tournaments, and tried to argue his company’s relationship to Sky was one of self-employment.   His appeal has been rejected, with almost all the usual “badges of trade” having failed. Sky…

Chris Ridgeon
1st November 2021 Budget: Hospitality Sector

Well, mixed news in the Budget for our hospitality sector, I would say.   A cut in business rates by 50% for qualifying businesses in retail, hospitality, and the leisure sector for a further year will hopefully help with that large overhead. No extension of the temporary reduced rate of VAT beyond 1 April 2022…

Emily Haines
27th October 2021 Budget: “Hooray for AIA!”

In the Chancellor’s Budget on 27 October 2021 it was announced that the planned date for reducing the Annual Investment Allowance limit from £1m to £200k is being extended from 1 January 2022 to 31 March 2023. This will effect businesses who are planning on investing more than £200k in plant and machinery from January…

Jeannette Hume
27th October 2021 Construction firm wins R&D tax relief case

A tax tribunal has made a landmark ruling against HMRC, by declaring that the construction taxpayer (Quinn) was validly entitled to claim SME research and development (R&D) tax relief totalling approximately £1m, even though this work was specifically undertaken to order for a customer, which would normally mean the ‘subsidised’ rule would prohibit eligibility under…